The National Transport Authority (NTA) has announced a ban on e-scooters on public transport, effective Monday, 7 October 2024. The decision follows recent legislation under the Road Traffic Act 2023, which legally recognised ‘Personal Powered Transporters’ (PPTs), including e-bicycles, e-mopeds, and e-scooters, as a mode of transport.
Scope of the Ban
The ban applies to all services operated under the NTA, including:
- Dublin Bus
- Iarnród Éireann
- Bus Éireann
- Luas
- DART
- Go-Ahead Ireland
- TFI Local Link
However, the restriction only applies to e-scooters and not other PPTs like e-bicycles and e-mopeds.
Reasons Behind the Ban
The primary reason for the ban is the fire risk associated with the lithium-ion batteries used to power e-scooters. These batteries are deemed flammable and, in some cases, explosive. Fires caused by lithium-ion batteries burn at temperatures between 1000-2000 degrees Celsius, posing a significant safety threat.
The risk of fire is heightened when the batteries are overcharged, exposed to water, damaged, short-circuited, or poorly manufactured. Until recently, quality control and manufacturing regulations on PPTs have been lacking, raising concerns about the safety of existing products.
Real-Life Incident
In October 2023, a fire tore through a train carriage in Madrid, reportedly started by an e-scooter’s lithium-ion battery. While no life was lost, the incident highlighted the potential dangers associated with these batteries.
Inconsistency in the Ban
Despite the ban on e-scooters, other PPTs like e-bicycles and e-mopeds, which also use lithium-ion batteries, are not included in the restriction. The NTA suggests that the placement of batteries in e-scooters makes them more vulnerable to damage, increasing the risk of fire compared to other PPTs.
Similar Measures in Other Cities
Dublin is not alone in taking this prohibitory stance. Other cities, such as London, Madrid, and Barcelona, have also banned e-scooters on public transport due to similar safety concerns.
Enforcement of the Ban
Public transport firms have pledged to enforce the new ban, with Iarnród Éireann implementing a €100 fine for anyone found infringing upon it.
Implications for E-Scooter Users
The ban is likely to cause inconvenience for e-scooter users who rely on public transport for their daily commute. Some users have expressed frustration, calling the ban “ludicrous, irritating, and very wrong.”
Retailers have also raised concerns about the potential impact on e-scooter sales, with some predicting a 50% reduction in sales following the ban.
The Future of Personal Mobility in Ireland
The ban on e-scooters highlights the need for a comprehensive review of personal mobility laws and regulations in Ireland. Key considerations include:
- Establishing clear safety standards for PPTs
- Improving quality control and manufacturing regulations
- Investing in infrastructure to accommodate PPTs safely
- Engaging with stakeholders to inform future policy decisions
As the government and statutory bodies navigate the emerging world of PPTs, finding a balance between safety and personal mobility will be crucial.
KOD Lyons’ Expertise in Transport Law
At KOD Lyons, our team of experienced solicitors closely monitors developments in transport law and the legal implications of new technologies. We provide expert advice and representation in matters related to:
- Road traffic accidents involving PPTs
- Personal injury claims arising from transport incidents
- Consumer rights in relation to PPTs
If you have been affected by the ban on e-scooters or have any other legal concerns related to transport, our knowledgeable solicitors are here to assist you. Contact us today to arrange a consultation and discuss your specific situation.
Related Services:
Get in touch
Leaders in our field and winners at the Irish Law awards we have proven expertise in immigration and international law, child and family law and personal injury litigation.
Tel: +353 1 679 0780
Email: info@kodlyons.ie